Psychiatry's Dirty Secret
Psychiatry's
Dirty Secret
We Were Trained to Manage Symptoms, Not Restore People
Medication can be lifesaving. But for many people, it becomes a kind of holding pattern. It helps them survive, but it doesn't always help them change. We've built a system that's excellent at managing symptoms but often forgets the harder, deeper work of restoring the person underneath.
Stabilization is necessary. Sometimes it's miraculous. But it is still only the beginning.
The Band-Aid
Imagine you cut your hand deeply. A Band-Aid stops the bleeding. It protects the wound. It gives your body a chance to start healing. But nobody confuses a Band-Aid with real treatment. To truly heal, you need to clean the wound, maybe stitch it, and then learn how to avoid cutting yourself the same way again.
In psychiatry, medication is often the Band-Aid. It can stop the emotional bleeding, quiet the storm, and make survival possible. Therapy is what cleans the wound, sets it up for proper healing, and teaches you how to live differently so the injury doesn't keep reopening.
Medication can be lifesaving — I've seen it pull people back from the edge when nothing else could. But here's the part we don't talk about enough: for many people, medication becomes a kind of holding pattern. It helps them survive, but it doesn't always help them change.
I went through the same training as most psychiatrists: medical school, long residency hours, endless nights on call, and a constant pressure to move quickly. That training teaches you to be sharp, responsible, and precise. It also teaches you to work fast. In many clinics, a standard psychiatry visit is 15 or 30 minutes. That's enough time to ask, "How are you sleeping? Any side effects? Should we adjust the dose?" It's often not enough time to ask, "What's actually going on in your life? What hurts? What are you afraid of? What do you want to change?"
That structure isn't an accident. It reflects how psychiatry is paid for. Brief medication visits are easier to schedule, easier to bill, and easier to fit into a busy day than longer therapy sessions. Over time, the field adapted. Since the 1990s, fewer and fewer psychiatrists have offered therapy at all.1 The result is a profession that's excellent at managing symptoms but often out of practice when it comes to helping people rebuild their lives.
Mental illness is rarely just a "chemical imbalance." Yes, the brain is involved. But so are your relationships, your history, your habits, your fears, and the stories you tell yourself about who you are. A pill might quiet the alarm system in your brain, but it can't teach you how to grieve, how to set boundaries, how to stop repeating the same painful patterns, or how to find meaning after loss.
We have a system that's excellent at managing symptoms but often forgets the harder, deeper work of restoring the person underneath.
Medication can be incredibly effective, but it has limits. In depression, for example, staying on an antidepressant after you feel better cuts the risk of relapse roughly in half compared with stopping it. One large review found that about 21% of people relapsed while continuing medication, versus about 40% who relapsed after stopping.2 That's powerful. It means medication helps. But notice the other side of those numbers: even with the right medication, one in five people still relapse. Medication helps you stay well, but it doesn't guarantee it.
That's where therapy comes in. Therapy isn't just "talking about your feelings." It's learning how your mind works, how your past shapes your present, and how to respond differently when life gets hard again. In some studies, people who received certain types of therapy relapsed less often than those who relied on medication alone. One study found that cognitive therapy reduced relapse from 47% to 29% over more than a year.3,4
The Evidence at a Glance
| Finding | Data Point | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Relapse with continued medication | ~21% relapse rate | Geddes et al., 2021 |
| Relapse after stopping medication | ~40% relapse rate | Geddes et al., 2021 |
| Relapse with cognitive therapy | Reduced from 47% → 29% | Paykel et al., 1999 |
| Psychiatrists offering therapy | Declined by ~half since 1990s | Olfson & Marcus, 2021 |
Medication can open the door to healing, but it isn't the healing itself. Sometimes you need medication first — when depression is so heavy you can't think clearly, or anxiety is so intense you can't leave the house. But once the fog lifts, the deeper work has to begin. Otherwise, you might feel quieter, but you're still stuck in the same patterns, the same fears, the same lonely places inside yourself.
The difference between barely staying afloat and actually learning to swim is not a small one — and it rarely comes from a prescription alone.
Another part of this story is what happens when one medication isn't enough. In psychiatry, it's common for people to end up on multiple medications at once. Studies suggest that more than one in three psychiatric patients are on several medications at the same time, and in some settings, the number is much higher.5,6
Sometimes that's necessary. Some people truly need more than one medication to stay stable. But from the patient's perspective, being on many medications often feels less like advanced treatment and more like this:
- More side effects — fatigue, brain fog, weight changes, sexual problems
- More confusion about what's helping and what's harming
- For older adults, more falls, more memory problems, and a lower quality of life7,8
- A sense of being managed rather than understood
When your treatment plan becomes a long list of pills, it's easy to start believing something like, "My brain must be really broken," or "No one actually knows what to do with me," or "The only answer to my pain is to suppress it." When medication is used without a real therapeutic relationship, it's easy to feel managed instead of understood.
A long medication list without an accompanying therapeutic relationship is not advanced treatment. It is symptom suppression without a map.
This is where therapy becomes essential. Therapy gives you and your psychiatrist a shared language. It helps us understand not just what your symptoms are, but what they're doing for you. It helps us ask questions like:
- What is this symptom protecting you from?
- What pain is too big to say out loud, so your body says it instead?
- What old wound keeps getting reopened in your current relationships?
- What part of you never got the chance to grow up?
Countertransference as a Clinical Tool
That's also where something called countertransference matters. In plain terms, countertransference is the emotional reaction a therapist has to a patient. If we're not careful, it can cloud our judgment. But if we use it thoughtfully, it becomes a tool. It can tell us something important about what it feels like to be in your world. It can reveal patterns you might not see yet.9
What Good Training Looks Like
I was lucky in my training. My residency program required three years of doing therapy with patients, supervised by an exceptional therapist named Dr. Garrison. She was part teacher, part mentor, part "human guru." That experience changed how I practice. It taught me that my job isn't just to prescribe. It's to understand.
It gave me a real language for people, not just diagnoses. It showed me that a psychiatrist can be both scientifically rigorous and deeply human. In many ways, that training let me do the job I always hoped I could do: not just reduce suffering, but help people become more whole.
A psychiatrist who has never done therapy is like a cardiologist who has never met a patient's family. The medicine might still work — but something essential is missing from the care.
Medication might lower your anxiety, but it won't answer questions like:
- Why do I keep ending up in the same kinds of painful relationships?
- Why do I shut down when I feel criticized?
- Why do I sabotage myself right when things start going well?
- Why do I need this symptom to express something I can't say directly?
Those aren't side issues. They're the real questions of healing.
Without therapy, many people are left to figure those things out on their own, often while still struggling with symptoms, limited insight, and a lot of confusing information from the internet. You might be told you're "doing better" because your panic attacks have decreased, even while your relationships are still falling apart or your sense of self still feels fragmented.
That creates a painful gap between being clinically stable and actually feeling recovered.
You deserve to understand what's happening in your mind and body. You deserve a clear explanation you can actually use. You deserve to be a partner in your care, not just a recipient of it. When treatment becomes a collaboration, healing becomes possible.
Being clinically stable is not the same as feeling recovered. The gap between those two things is where the real work — and the real healing — lives.
The Band-Aid metaphor isn't meant to dismiss medication. It's meant to be honest about its limits. Medications can stop the bleeding. They can lower the fever. They can keep you safe long enough for the deeper work to begin. But if the work stops there, we've managed symptoms without really restoring the person.
That's the deeper problem in psychiatry: too often, we celebrate stabilization as if it were transformation. It's not. Stabilization is necessary. Sometimes it's miraculous. But it's still only the beginning.
Psychiatry should be about both science and meaning, both medicine and relationship, both symptom relief and restoration. Medication has a crucial place. It should remain a core part of our work. But if we want to truly help people, we have to stop pretending that symptom management is the same thing as healing.
The deeper problem in psychiatry: we celebrate stabilization as if it were transformation. It is not. Stabilization is the prerequisite for healing — not the destination.
A Path Back to Yourself
You deserve more than a Band-Aid. You deserve a path back to yourself.
The work of psychiatry, done well, is not about managing a brain. It is about accompanying a person — through the fog, through the history, through the hard questions — until they can carry themselves forward again. That requires medication when it's needed. It requires therapy when it's possible. And it always requires the willingness to see the person underneath the symptoms.
We were not built to be just stable. We were built to be whole.
Notes
Chicago Style. Superscript numbers throughout the essay link to the corresponding entry below.
- 1Olfson, Mark, and Steven C. Marcus. "Talk Therapy by U.S. Psychiatrists Declined by Half Since 1990s." Columbia Psychiatry News, December 6, 2021. columbiapsychiatry.org
- 2Geddes, John R., et al. "Discontinuation of Antidepressants after Remission with Maintenance Treatment in Major Depressive Disorder." Molecular Psychiatry 26 (2021): 392–99. nature.com
- 3Cuijpers, Pim, et al. "Enduring Effects of Psychotherapy, Antidepressants and Their Combination in the Treatment of Depression." Frontiers in Psychiatry 15 (2024): 1415905. frontiersin.org
- 4Paykel, E. S., et al. "Prevention of Relapse in Residual Depression by Cognitive Therapy." Archives of General Psychiatry 56, no. 9 (1999): 829–35. jamanetwork.com
- 5Al-Jumaili, Abdulrahman M., and Carrie G. Witry. "Prevalence and Factors Associated with Polypharmacy in Psychiatry." BMC Psychiatry 22 (2022): 467. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- 6Correll, Christoph U., et al. "Prevalence, Correlates, Tolerability-Related Outcomes, and Efficacy of Antipsychotic Polypharmacy." The Lancet Psychiatry 11, no. 12 (2024): 987–1001. thelancet.com
- 7Rhee, Teresa G., and Thomas M. Olchanski. "Polypharmacy in Older Adults with Psychiatric Disorders." Psychiatric Times, May 28, 2024. psychiatrictimes.com
- 8Pham, Ngoc T., et al. "Polypharmacy and Health-Related Quality of Life and Psychological Distress among US Adults." Preventing Chronic Disease 19 (2022): E53. cdc.gov
- 9American Psychological Association. "How to Manage Countertransference in Therapy." Monitor on Psychology, September 2025. apa.org
"You deserve more than a Band-Aid. You deserve a path back to yourself."
Learn About Alignment Psychiatry